West TN Historic Home for Sale w/ Fenced Pasture & Stocked Pond

Historic 1920 Colonial Revival Farmhouse on 8.5 Acres for Sale in Rutherford, TN

Equine-Ready | Pond | Log Cabin | Workshop

Step back in time while enjoying modern comfort with this historic Early American equine farmhouse for sale in Rutherford, Tennessee. Built in 1920, this stunning Colonial Revival farmhouse sits on 8.5 level, usable acres and offers nearly 4,914 square feet of beautifully preserved living space—the kind of property people move to West Tennessee to find.

From the moment you arrive, the classic front columns and wide covered porch welcome you into a lifestyle rooted in charm, space, and privacy. Inside, you’ll find hardwood floors, a formal traditional entry, oversized 18×18 bedrooms, multiple sitting areas, a large bonus room, and a sunroom wrapped in windows with sweeping views of the acreage. The formal dining room is perfect for entertaining, while the skylights and gas log fireplace insert add warmth and natural light throughout the living areas.

The chef’s kitchen features quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, double ovens, an oversized sink, skylights, and a walk-in pantry—ideal for anyone who loves to cook or entertain. Modern upgrades include thermopane windows, spray foam insulation, natural gas, high-speed internet, and underground utilities, blending historic character with today’s conveniences.

Outdoor Features Perfect for Horses, Farming & Recreation

• 8.5 fully usable acres ideal for horses, livestock, or hobby farming

• Large, well-stocked pond just steps from the home

• Mature shade trees, pecan trees, myrtle bushes & long farmland views

• Authentic 1800s log cabin adding rich history and character

• 30×40 wired workshop, plus additional outbuilding & hay storage

• Fenced livestock area

• Outdoor grilling area & gazebo overlooking the water

This land offers space to ride, farm, garden, fish, or simply unplug and enjoy Tennessee living at its best. The property also carries a unique sense of history, sitting in the same West Tennessee landscape once crossed by Davy Crockett.

944 McKnight Street, Rutherford, TN 38369

Offered at $549,900

⭐ Link to full listing, additional details & photos in the comments

If you’re searching for a historic farmhouse with land for sale in West Tennessee, an equine property in Rutherford, TN, or a country home with pond, workshop, and acreage, this one checks every box.

About Rutherford, TN

Rutherford, Tennessee offers a welcoming small-town atmosphere with convenient access to nearby cities, making it an ideal location for families and homebuyers seeking a balanced lifestyle. This charming community features a mix of single-family homes, modern subdivisions, and affordable real estate opportunities, all surrounded by scenic landscapes and local amenities. Whether you’re searching for homes for sale in Rutherford, TN, or exploring investment properties in this growing area, the city provides a thriving real estate market with options to suit every lifestyle and budget.

Contact Bradley Arnold – Southern Lifestyle Properties

Bradley Arnold is a seasoned real estate professional with over two decades of experience, specializing in niche properties like golf homes, equine estates, and luxury residences in West Tennessee. Growing up in a real estate family, Bradley’s deep knowledge of the local market, paired with five national designations, ensures expert guidance for buyers and sellers. Outside of real estate, he enjoys spending time with family, watching sports, and serving his community.

Contact Madalyn Ostrander – Southern Lifestyle Properties

Madalyn Ostrander is a highly skilled real estate agent in West Tennessee, specializing in residential lifestyle properties and land listings. As an FAA-certified drone pilot and digital marketing expert, she showcases properties with stunning aerial visuals while ensuring maximum online exposure. With certifications as a Seller Representative Specialist (SRS) and Pricing Strategy Advisor (PSA), Madalyn provides expert pricing and negotiation support, making each real estate transaction seamless and stress-free.