Restored Historic Home with Original Charm in Spencer IN For Sale

Own a true piece of Owen County history with Heavenridge House, a beautifully preserved 1907 Arts & Crafts bungalow located on a prominent corner lot in the heart of Spencer, Indiana. Offering 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and over 3,000 square feet of living space, this one-of-a-kind home blends timeless architectural details with thoughtful modern updates.

From the inviting stone front porch to the original cherry woodwork and hardwood floors, every room reflects the exceptional craftsmanship of a bygone era while providing the comfort and functionality today’s homeowners appreciate.

Property Highlights

• Historic 1907 Arts & Crafts bungalow
  
• 4 bedrooms | 2 full bathrooms
  
• 3,054± square feet of living space
  
• Desirable corner lot in downtown Spencer
  
• Original cherry woodwork and hardwood flooring
  
• Grand foyer with elegant original staircase
  
• Stone gas-log fireplace in the spacious living room
  
• Formal dining room with classic butler’s pantry
  
• Updated kitchen with custom built-ins and tile flooring
  
• Main-level flex room perfect for a bedroom, office, or den
  
• Renovated main-floor bathroom (2023)
  
• Large upstairs bathroom with double vanity, soaking tub & walk-in shower
  
• Bonus room ideal for a home office, hobby room, or storage
  
• Detached two-car garage with composite entertaining deck
  
• Beautiful mature landscaping featuring rare Spencer stone
  
• Fenced backyard for pets, gardening, or outdoor enjoyment
  
• Partial basement with interior and exterior access
  
• Natural gas heat, central air, city utilities, and owned water softener

Step inside and you’ll immediately appreciate the home’s warm character. The grand foyer welcomes guests with rich original woodwork and beautiful hardwood floors that continue throughout much of the home. Large windows fill the oversized living room with natural light, while the striking stone gas-log fireplace creates the perfect gathering place for family and friends.

The formal dining room is ideal for entertaining and flows seamlessly into the kitchen through the original butler’s pantry, preserving the home’s historic charm. The updated kitchen features custom cabinetry, built-in shelving, updated tile flooring, an electric range with built-in downdraft vent, and picturesque views of the surrounding gardens. An attached rear porch serves as a convenient mudroom for everyday living.

The main level also includes a beautifully renovated full bathroom and a versatile flex room that can function as a fourth bedroom, home office, library, or additional living space.

Upstairs, you’ll find three spacious bedrooms and a generously sized full bathroom complete with double vanities, a relaxing soaking tub, and a walk-in shower. A second staircase leads to the laundry landing and an additional bonus room, offering endless possibilities for a craft room, reading nook, playroom, or extra storage.

Outside, the property is equally impressive. Mature landscaping, established gardens accented with rare Spencer stone, and a fenced backyard create a peaceful outdoor retreat. The detached two-car garage and adjoining composite deck provide the perfect setting for summer barbecues, entertaining guests, or simply relaxing outdoors.

Located in the charming community of Spencer, this historic home offers convenient access to local shopping, dining, schools, and nearby outdoor recreation, including McCormick’s Creek State Park. Bloomington is just a short drive away, making this property ideal for those seeking small-town charm with easy access to city amenities.

If you’re searching for a historic home for sale in Spencer, Indiana, an Arts & Crafts home in Owen County, or a beautifully maintained property filled with original character and modern conveniences, Heavenridge House is a truly rare opportunity.

Listed by Gabrielle Getts
United Country Coffey Realty & Auction
812-340-3295

Schedule your private showing today and discover the timeless beauty, craftsmanship, and history of Heavenridge House.